Why songs help people learn science (and when they don't)
Songs reliably make science lessons more enjoyable and engaging. They can also help students remember facts, but only under certain conditions, and the research has not shown that they beat good teaching without music.
- 86%of surveyed students found science songs at least somewhat enjoyable (Crowther 2012)
- 68%found them at least somewhat helpful for learning
- 13 of 15song videos raised scores on targeted questions in a study of about 1,000 students
What the studies found
Enjoyment and engagement are the most reliable benefit. In a survey reported by biologist Greg Crowther in 2012, most students said songs made class more enjoyable, and about two in three said they helped. A qualitative study of six middle-school classes (Governor, Hall and Jackson, 2013) found that students and teachers saw songs as a way to raise interest and as a memory aid. Those studies describe experiences. They do not prove that songs cause better learning.
Recall improves only when the melody is simple and repeated. In a classic memory experiment, Wallace (1994) found that sung text was recalled better than spoken text only when the melody was simple and repeated across several verses, so listeners learned it well. With a single verse, the benefit disappeared or even reversed. A 2016 review (Ferreri and Verga) reached a similar, mixed conclusion: it depends on how complex the melody and the words are.
Singing helped adults learn foreign phrases in one lab study. Ludke, Ferreira and Overy (2014) taught 60 adults short Hungarian phrases. People who learned by singing did better than those who learned by speaking. That was a single 15-minute session, so it shows what is possible, not what happens over a school year.
What songs have not shown
A large study of science music videos (Crowther, McFadden, Fleming and Davis, 2016) involved about 1,000 mostly K–12 students. Scores on targeted questions went up after 13 of the 15 videos. But when the researchers compared music videos with non-music videos covering the same content, the scores were similar. Students preferred the music versions. In one of the studies, immediate scores were actually higher for the non-music version.
So the honest summary is: a song is a pleasant, memorable way to deliver content, and about as effective as a good non-music explanation. It is not a shortcut.
How to get the real benefit
Two study habits have strong evidence behind them. Dunlosky and colleagues (2013) rated practice testing (quizzing yourself) and distributed practice (spreading study over days) as “high utility” techniques. Roediger and Karpicke (2006) showed that taking a test on material helped long-term memory more than re-reading it.
- Use a simple, familiar melody and repeat the chorus.
- Check the lyrics for accuracy before students learn them.
- After the song, quiz students without the music: can they explain the idea in their own words?
- Bring the song back a few days later, and again a week later, with a short quiz each time.
The pages below put this into practice: how to use songs in class, how to write one, and memory tricks that work alongside them.
- Songs in the classroomWhen to use a science song, how to check one for accuracy, five classroom activities, linking songs to retrieval practice, and including students who won’t sing.
- Write a science songWrite a science song in seven steps: pick one concept, list the key facts, choose a public-domain tune, match syllables and stress, check accuracy, record and share it.
- Run a song contestPlan a student science-song contest: a rules template, grade-level categories, a scoring rubric that weights accuracy highest, consent for recordings, and free prizes.
- Memory tricksChecked science mnemonics for planets, taxonomy, redox, the spectrum, SOH-CAH-TOA, metric prefixes, mitosis, resistors and the Krebs cycle, plus what research says.
- Copyright for songsUS copyright basics for science songs: classroom performance, why posting online differs, fair use and parody, public-domain tunes, Happy Birthday, and Creative Commons.
Sources
- Crowther G. (2012). Using science songs to enhance learning: an interdisciplinary approach. CBE—Life Sciences Education 11:26–30
- Crowther G., McFadden T., Fleming J., Davis K. (2016). Leveraging the power of music to improve science education. International Journal of Science Education 38:73–95
- Governor D., Hall J., Jackson D. (2013). Teaching and learning science through song. International Journal of Science Education 35(18):3117–3140
- Wallace W. T. (1994). Memory for music: effect of melody on recall of text. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition 20:1471–1485
- Ferreri L., Verga L. (2016). Benefits of music on verbal learning and memory. Music Perception 34(2):167–182
- Ludke K. M., Ferreira F., Overy K. (2014). Singing can facilitate foreign language learning. Memory & Cognition 42:41–52
- Roediger H. L., Karpicke J. D. (2006). Test-enhanced learning. Psychological Science 17:249–255
- Dunlosky J. et al. (2013). Improving students’ learning with effective learning techniques. Psychological Science in the Public Interest 14:4–58